I don't think I'm very qualified to answer this for you - as I've only used one type of running line, so can't give much of a comparison.
However, I can tell you that I've been very happy with my choice, to this point - and I purchased the ones I own after doing a fair bit of reading on spey fishing forums.
I have 30lb Ridgeline connected to a Rio skagit head (650gr) for a 12'6'' 9wt Echo2 and a 20lb Ridgeline connected to a 300gr Airflo compact scandi for an 11'9'' 4wt Decho.
I haven't had even a single tangling problem, despite some sub zero weather this winter - and regardless of whether I hold coils in my hand or let it hang in the current.
It shoots very, very well - though again, I have nothing to compare it to except single handed lines - and I haven't had any problems with dirt building up in the ridges, to this point.
The advantage of a running line, for me - is that if I decide to run a compact skagit on the Decho 4 with tips for Summer Runs, instead of the scandi - I don't need another reel spool. I just switch out the head (the Ridgeline comes with an extra large front loop to make pulling a coiled head through very easy) and I'm back to fishing.



Reply With Quote


Bookmarks